Italian food at Osteria Italian Restaurant in Shrewsbury is celebrated for its authenticity, offering diners a true taste of Italy.
Authentic Italian cuisine hinges on simplicity, fresh ingredients, and traditional techniques, all of which are cornerstones of Osteria’s approach. The restaurant prides itself on sourcing high-quality, seasonal ingredients that emphasise the natural flavours of each dish. Ingredients like ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, rich olive oil, and locally sourced cheeses are staples, ensuring each meal is packed with genuine Italian flavour.
One of the defining characteristics of Osteria’s authenticity is its adherence to Italian culinary traditions. The chefs here use time-honoured methods that have been passed down through generations, honouring Italy’s regional diversity. For instance, pasta is made fresh in-house, just as it would be in Italian kitchens, giving diners a taste of homemade quality. Sauces are crafted from scratch with minimal but well-chosen ingredients, allowing each flavour to shine without overwhelming the palate — a classic Italian philosophy.
Osteria’s menu reflects the variety of Italian cuisine, showcasing regional dishes from places like Tuscany, Sicily, and Emilia-Romagna. This regional representation in the menu, from creamy risottos to hearty, slow-cooked ragù, highlights the diversity of Italy’s culinary landscape. Additionally, Osteria emphasises wine pairings, curating selections that complement the authentic Italian flavours of each dish, further enhancing the dining experience with wines imported directly from Italian vineyards.
Lastly, Osteria’s atmosphere contributes to the authenticity. The welcoming environment mirrors the ambiance of an Italian osteria, where meals are shared in a relaxed, family-oriented setting. Together, these elements — the focus on fresh ingredients, traditional preparation, regional variety, and inviting atmosphere —create an authentic Italian dining experience.
Read our reviews
Best experience and food I have had in a long time
We just the tastiest dinner at Osteria this evening! I have not eaten such rich and tasty food in a very long time. Up there with the best food in Shrewsbury, I wouldn’t change a thing. The service was amazing, it was an authentic Italian experience and the timings and food were 5* for a very reasonable price. We felt so well looked after and had a fantastic evening. We will be back for more!
Fay
4 June 2024
An amazing restaurant, worth the hype
I have to recommend the pork belly, both the nibbles and the main are amazing! The dough balls are out of this world gone so fast that I couldn’t even snap up a photo of them.
We’ve sampled the pasta (ravioli and a carbonara that I thought I wouldn’t see outside of Italy) and the risotto (sausage) as well as the award winning pork dish.
I promise you we will be back to try the pizza.
Everything is unexpected, with twists of anise and hints of subtle and deep wine, or other components you’ve never thought of, but once you taste them you wonder why you’ve never considered them before.
Nothing is taken for granted and yet you’re given so much more than you asked for.
An unforgettable experience in Italian dining!
Bone
January 2024
Gorgeous food
Delicious pizza and seafood pasta was the best we ever had.Service was wonderful drinks were very nice as well.10/10 experience.
Stelios V
August 2024
Best Italian food ever
Jun 2024 • Friends
The best Italian food I’ve ever had in my life. The food was so flavourful and cooked to perfection, I highly recommend coming here for any occasion, it simply is the perfect meal. The service was lovely and the drinks were nice as well!
Sara N
June 2024
Gorgeous food.
Aug 2024 • Friends
Delicious pizza and seafood pasta was the best we ever had.Service was wonderful drinks were very nice as well.10/10 experience.
Stelios V
1 August 2024
Delicious pasta carbonara
Had a lovely anniversary meal here. The waiter was very attentive and looked after us well. After reading the reviews we had to try the ‘Carbonara’. We weren’t disappointed, it was delicious, very delicate and very different in a good way. I encourage you to try it. The lasagne was also excellent as was the tiramisu. The Tuscan bean salad was a highlight. Definitely will be our ‘go to’ restaurant next time we’re in Shrewsbury.
PhoneJoan
August 2024
Carrying the torch of Italian food in Shrewsbury
Fantastic as always!! We were a last minute booking and we were seated and served our drinks promptly. The food was fantastic. We shared a selection of delicious starters. My partner had the authentic carbonara and I had the ravioli. We both finished off with a traditional Tiramisu. We look forward to our next visit.
Ash 96
July 2024
Impromptu Italian…we’ll be back!
Jun 2024 • Couples
Visited on a Monday night and it was still quite busy, which we thought bodes well. Attentive and service, unique menu, and everything was cooked together perfection. This is far from your usual day to day Italian. It is pricey, more like a special occasion kind of place. We will be surprised if there’s a better restaurant in Shrewsbury town centre.
Table for 2
3 June 2024
Seafood pasta looks amazing
Brilliant food, I’d order the seafood pasta if I went again as it looked amazing. We let them know it was my mother’s in laws birthday and they were amazing in helping her celebrate. Quality of food was fantastic, and the service was attentive, friendly and genuine.
Fiona Gibbs
June 2024